Industry consolidation reduces the number of potential buyers, often leading to lower valuations for small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs). As larger companies dominate the market, businesses with operational inefficiencies or poor financial records may see their valuations decline, while well-prepared companies can still command higher prices. Buyers now prioritize scalability, operational readiness, and clear financial records, making strategic acquisitions at favorable terms more common.
Seller Notes, Earnouts, and SBA: The Building Blocks of a Main Street Deal
Industry consolidation is reshaping how small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) are valued. Here’s what you need to know:
Fewer Buyers, Lower Prices: As industries consolidate, the number of potential buyers shrinks, often leading to reduced SMB valuations. However, businesses with strong financials and unique strengths can still command higher prices.
What Buyers Want: Buyers now prioritize operational readiness, scalability, and clean financial records over simple profitability.
Challenges for Sellers: SMBs with poor financial transparency, inefficiencies, or outdated processes often face valuation declines.
Opportunities for Buyers: Consolidation creates a buyer’s market, offering strategic acquisition opportunities at favorable terms.
How to Prepare: Sellers can boost valuations by improving operations, documenting processes, and adopting modern technology. Buyers can leverage AI tools to identify undervalued businesses and streamline acquisitions.
Key Takeaway: Whether you’re selling or buying, understanding how consolidation affects valuations is critical. For sellers, focus on operational efficiency and financial clarity. For buyers, seek businesses with clear strengths and use technology to gain an edge.
How To Value a Business for Sale (Mergers and Acquisitions)
How Industry Consolidation Changes SMB Valuations
Industry consolidation reshapes how small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) are valued, primarily by reducing the number of potential buyers and altering what makes a business attractive. This section takes a closer look at how these changes impact valuation metrics and the broader market.
Fewer Buyers Lead to Lower Prices
When industries consolidate, the pool of potential buyers shrinks, often leading to lower valuations for SMBs. As larger players dominate market share, the number of active participants decreases, creating a buyer's market. In this environment, SMBs may struggle to attract competitive offers, which can result in reduced valuation multiples [3]. However, businesses with strong financials and well-defined competitive advantages still manage to stand out and command attention [2].
"Consolidation is about transferring value from the inefficient to the efficient. Technology simply accelerates this transfer."
– Rob Hale, Founder of Granite Telecommunications[1]
Consider Bain Capital's 2024 Private Equity Report, which highlights that over 30% of service businesses in the U.S. remain fragmented, with no single company holding more than a 5% market share [1]. While this fragmentation creates opportunities for strategic buyers, SMBs without clear strengths often experience downward pressure on their valuations.
What Buyers Want Now
Modern buyers expect much more than just profitability. They prioritize businesses that are ready for seamless integration and scalable growth. Key factors include transparent financial records, well-documented processes, strong employee retention, and integrated technology that enhances efficiency after acquisition [1][4].
Buyers increasingly demand evidence of operational readiness, such as clear growth plans and standard operating procedures. This shift has moved the focus away from simple revenue multiples to a deeper examination of a business’s ability to integrate and scale [4]. While this trend benefits well-prepared firms, those with operational or financial weaknesses face greater challenges in maintaining competitive valuations.
Why Some Businesses Get Lower Valuations
Not all SMBs are equally equipped to thrive in a consolidating market. Businesses that fail to adapt often see their valuations drop, particularly if they have operational or financial shortcomings. For instance, unclear financial statements, inconsistent reporting, or undocumented revenue streams can deter buyers and lead to lower offers [4].
Operational inefficiencies also play a significant role in reducing valuations. Companies without succession plans, retention strategies, or scalable processes are perceived as riskier investments. In service industries where labor accounts for 60–80% of costs [1], the inability to demonstrate operational efficiency can be especially damaging.
Valuation Factor
High-Value SMBs
Low-Value SMBs
Financial Records
Clean, audited statements
Inconsistent or unclear reporting
Key Personnel
Retention plans in place
High turnover risk
Processes
Documented and scalable
Ad-hoc or owner-dependent
Technology
Modern, integrated systems
Outdated or fragmented tools
The consolidation trend shows no signs of slowing. Private equity firms, armed with over $1 trillion in committed capital [5], continue to push for higher standards. For SMBs, this means that meeting these elevated expectations is critical to securing favorable valuations. At the same time, businesses that are well-prepared and clearly differentiate themselves can still achieve premium pricing in a competitive market.
"The best businesses are built through patterns of decisions, not one-time home runs."
– Will Thorndike, The Outsider CEOs [1]
For both buyers and sellers, understanding these valuation dynamics is crucial in today’s rapidly consolidating industries.
How Sellers Can Get Better Valuations
Small business owners navigating industry consolidation don’t have to settle for lower valuations. By preparing strategically and making targeted improvements, businesses can attract higher offers - even in markets favoring buyers. The secret lies in showcasing operational efficiency, financial clarity, and technological preparedness, all of which appeal to potential buyers.
Getting Your Operations Ready
Strong operations are the cornerstone of higher valuations, especially when buyers have limited choices and higher expectations. Jeffrey Bartel, a Forbes Councils Member, highlights that improving operations is a preferred way to boost value because it enhances performance and creates scalable opportunities with less risk for buyers [6].
Start with an operational audit to identify areas needing improvement. Focus on three key areas: talent management, supply chain efficiency, and technology infrastructure[6]. Address staffing gaps and invest in leadership development to counter high labor costs, particularly in service industries.
Document all essential processes by creating Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs). This ensures your business can function smoothly without relying heavily on the owner [8].
"The importance of operational excellence stands crucial for both investors and buyers because it requires businesses to demonstrate efficiency along with scalability and powerful leadership. The combination of stability and future growth potential attracts investors who feel confident about the business direction due to controlled risks, increased profits and visible strategic plans." [6]
Tackle inefficiencies by cutting waste, boosting productivity, and improving service quality [7]. For instance, route optimization can increase productivity by 20–30%, while predictive maintenance can cut emergency calls by up to 40% [1].
Encourage collaboration across departments by setting unified company goals and clarifying individual roles in achieving them [7]. Poor communication, which causes 28% of employees to miss deadlines, can be a silent killer of productivity [7]. Once operations are streamlined, you can shift focus to financial clarity.
Using Financial Data to Set Prices
Clean, organized financial records are key to justifying your asking price and ensuring accurate valuations [9]. Aim to maintain at least three years of clean financial records before listing your business for sale [9].
Consider hiring professional accounting services to produce standardized financial documents that meet buyer expectations [9]. Well-maintained financials build buyer confidence, simplify due diligence, and prevent delays that could derail negotiations.
Highlight critical financial metrics such as net profit margins, gross turnover, and liquidity ratios[9]. Document every transaction to make verification easier during due diligence, and regularly review financial statements to catch and resolve issues early.
Use trends and forecasts based on accurate bookkeeping to support higher valuations [9]. Demonstrating consistent growth, improved efficiency, and clear revenue projections shows buyers that your business isn’t just profitable now but is positioned for long-term success.
Introduce formal financial controls to ensure the accuracy of your records [10]. This not only strengthens your budgeting and financial stability but also signals to buyers that your business has solid management practices in place [10].
Using Technology to Prepare for Sale
Modern technology infrastructure can significantly boost buyer confidence and your valuation. Around 25% of small businesses have adopted AI, and 95% use at least one technology platform [11]. Businesses leveraging AI often see a 12-point increase in their likelihood of profit growth compared to those that don’t [11].
Automation and integrated systems that reduce manual work and errors are particularly appealing to buyers [7]. As Ella Steinmetz-Simon, COO at 14Minds, advises:
"Every single company should be investing in automation and software that works for the company. Put the money into it - every single penny is worth it. Remember that just because certain software was popular six months ago, doesn't mean it's right today. Always be on the lookout for new technology and new opportunities to automate." [8]
Platforms like Clearly Acquired can simplify your sale preparation. Their AI-powered tools provide market valuation insights, connect you with verified buyers, and streamline the sale process with automated financial modeling and deal management features. These tools demonstrate to buyers that your business is technologically advanced and ready to meet modern demands.
Adopt data analytics to continually evaluate your business’s performance and value [12]. Emerging technologies like AI and machine learning are increasingly used in mergers and acquisitions to streamline data gathering and uncover hidden value [12]. This capability shows buyers that your business can integrate seamlessly with their existing technology.
Run pilot programs with new technologies to prove your commitment to innovation [12]. Train team members at all levels to use digital tools effectively, demonstrating that your workforce is ready for a tech-driven future [12].
"You should be thinking about 3-, 5- and 10-year goals and how to get there. That means aligning your investments and innovation to your longer-term strategic objectives. If it isn't going to work a year from now, it isn't right for your business." [8]
sbb-itb-a3ef7c1
How Buyers Can Find Good Deals in Consolidating Industries
As industries consolidate, buyers are presented with unique chances to make strategic acquisitions. While sellers may face pricing pressures, buyers can take advantage of market conditions to secure acquisitions on favorable terms. Success hinges on accessing quality deal flow, securing the right financing, and leveraging modern tools to streamline the acquisition process.
Finding the Right Businesses to Buy
The secret to uncovering profitable opportunities lies in casting a wider net while focusing on high-quality prospects. Savvy buyers don’t rely on just one source - they tap into multiple channels to maximize their options and improve their chances of finding undervalued businesses.
Diversify your deal sourcing approach by exploring broker listings, online marketplaces, and off-market opportunities [13]. Many of the best deals never make it to public listings, especially in consolidating industries where competition for visible opportunities is fierce.
Prioritize businesses with clear and transparent financial records[13]. In a consolidating market, buyers can afford to be selective. Focus on targets that demonstrate solid financial controls and detailed reporting. While these businesses may come with higher price tags, they typically involve less risk and integrate more smoothly.
Platforms like Clearly Acquired give buyers access to over 3.2 million businesses across 50+ industries, with $6.5 million in monthly business sales [13]. This breadth allows buyers to compare opportunities across sectors and identify patterns that signal good value.
Verify the parties involved to ensure trust and transparency [13]. In a buyer’s market, thorough due diligence can protect you from potential pitfalls and ensure each deal meets your standards.
Look for businesses that align with your current operations or offer strategic advantages, such as expanding your market reach, targeting new customer segments, or creating operational synergies. These opportunities can generate returns that go beyond the initial purchase price. Once you identify potential acquisitions, securing the right financing becomes crucial.
Getting the Right Financing
The financing structure you choose can significantly impact the success of your acquisition, especially in industries where cash flow and integration costs are key factors. Several financing options are available, each with distinct benefits depending on your situation.
SBA 7(a) loans, for example, provide up to $5 million in funding with terms extending to 25 years. They require a minimum equity contribution of 10% of project costs, with interest rates ranging from 10.5% to 14% [14][15]. The SBA guarantees 85% of loans up to $150,000 and 75% for amounts above that [15].
Seller financing is another useful option, particularly in consolidating industries where sellers are eager to close deals quickly. Seller notes on full standby may even count toward the equity requirement under SBA guidelines [14].
Prepare a sources and uses of funds table to detail all acquisition costs and funding sources [14]. This document not only helps lenders understand your financial strategy but also demonstrates your level of preparation. Include cash, investments, business assets, and any seller financing in your breakdown.
Work with experienced SBA lenders who understand the nuances of consolidating industries [15]. Lenders may be more selective in these markets, so a well-prepared financial plan is essential. Beyond financing, advanced technology tools can further streamline the acquisition process.
Using AI and Deal Management Tools
In industries reshaped by consolidation, technology offers buyers a major edge. AI-powered platforms can analyze vast amounts of data to pinpoint undervalued opportunities, simplify due diligence, and reduce research costs[16].
For instance, in October 2024, Normandy Advisors used Grata, an AI-powered dealmaking platform, to identify prospects for over 15 projects [16]. Azul, another firm, saved $120,000 annually in research costs by adopting an AI platform, which sped up the process of finding potential targets [16].
Platforms like Clearly Acquired provide buyers with verified deal flow and automated financial analyses, making it easier to compare opportunities. Features such as advanced search tools, interactive dashboards, and messaging systems streamline the entire acquisition process - from finding leads to closing deals [13].
Focus on high-impact AI applications like deal sourcing and due diligence [16]. Tools that offer proprietary data and insights can give you a competitive edge by identifying undervalued opportunities or potential risks that manual analysis might miss.
Establish strong data governance policies and conduct regular audits of your AI systems to address vulnerabilities [16]. Clear guidelines for ethical AI use in mergers and acquisitions are essential, as is fostering a data-driven mindset within your organization.
"You don't have to be the first adopter, but you don't want to be the last one either. Finding that point in time where it matches up for you is really valuable." [17]
Enrico Magnani, founding partner at Magnum Capital Partners, highlights the transformative potential of AI:
"I like to think about AI as a bicycle for your mind. Let's say your brain used to walk, and then you hop on a bicycle: A whole new world of opportunities opens up." [17]
Continuously evaluate and refine your AI tools and strategies [16]. With technology evolving rapidly, staying up-to-date with new capabilities can provide ongoing advantages in deal sourcing and execution.
Conclusion: Dealing with Industry Consolidation Changes
Navigating industry consolidation requires a combination of preparation, smart use of technology, and a deep understanding of shifting market dynamics. Success in this environment hinges on operational efficiency and recognizing the challenges and opportunities consolidation presents.
For sellers, achieving top valuations comes down to operational improvements and financial clarity. As Jon Holz from Riveron puts it:
"Taking the time to better position a business for sale by increasing EBITDA is time well spent" [21]
This means streamlining operations, optimizing revenue cycles, cutting unnecessary administrative costs, and maintaining transparent financial records. Businesses that focus on these areas often secure better valuations, even in markets where buyers hold more leverage. These strategies align with the market trends discussed earlier.
Buyers, on the other hand, face a different set of challenges. Their success depends on finding high-quality opportunities, securing the right financing, and conducting thorough due diligence. Rob Hale, founder of Granite Telecommunications, explains:
"Consolidation is about transferring value from the inefficient to the efficient. Technology simply accelerates this transfer" [1]
Technology plays a pivotal role in this process. Over 60% of businesses are already using or planning to use AI [18], which can cut post-merger integration costs by 15–30% and speed up integration timelines by about seven months [1]. Similarly, cloud-based solutions - adopted by 71% of small and medium-sized businesses for new applications [20] - offer enterprise-level capabilities without massive upfront costs.
The pressure to adapt is clear in the numbers. About 65% of customers expect businesses to adjust to their changing preferences [18], and 86% of companies have already shifted their marketing strategies based on customer interactions [18]. For small businesses, which make up 99% of U.S. companies and contribute up to 60% of the economy [19], ignoring these trends isn’t an option.
Platforms like Clearly Acquired are stepping in to help businesses adapt. By providing verified business listings, AI-driven deal management tools, and a range of financing options - including SBA loans, commercial loans, and equity solutions - they address key challenges for both buyers and sellers. These tools simplify the acquisition process and align with the strategies discussed throughout this article.
In the end, businesses that thrive in a consolidating market share a few key traits: they focus on building lasting customer relationships, embrace automation, and maintain financial discipline while investing strategically in growth. These approaches, highlighted throughout this article, are essential for navigating the complexities of consolidation.
Consolidation isn’t going anywhere. Companies that recognize this shift and take action now will be better positioned to secure higher valuations as sellers or make smart acquisitions as buyers. The time to act is now - use the tools and strategies at your disposal to stay ahead.
FAQs
What steps can small and medium-sized businesses take to increase their valuations in a consolidating industry?
To boost their valuation in a consolidating market, small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) should prioritize improving efficiency and profitability. This can be achieved by cutting unnecessary costs, refining workflows, and maintaining solid profit margins - all of which make the business more appealing to potential buyers.
Another critical step is to embrace technology. By adopting tools that enhance customer experiences and improve service offerings, SMBs can stay competitive and stand out in their industry. Showcasing a distinct value proposition, whether it's expertise in a specific niche or offering innovative products, can also make a business more attractive to acquirers.
Lastly, forming strategic partnerships or alliances can help SMBs expand their market presence and strengthen their operational capabilities. These collaborations can position the business as a more compelling acquisition target. By focusing on these strategies, SMBs can significantly improve their standing in a consolidating industry.
What do buyers look for when assessing businesses in a consolidating market?
When buyers evaluate businesses in a consolidating market, there are several critical factors they typically consider. Financial performance is at the top of the list, with steady revenue, solid profitability, and manageable debt being key indicators of a healthy business. These elements help buyers gauge the financial stability and potential of the acquisition.
Another major factor is the purchase price and related costs. Buyers need to ensure the investment aligns with their budget and delivers the expected return. A deal that stretches finances or underperforms on returns can quickly become a poor investment.
Buyers also prioritize potential synergies that can be unlocked after the acquisition. This could mean cutting costs, expanding into new markets, or improving operational efficiency. These synergies often represent the added value that makes an acquisition worthwhile.
The strategic fit of the business is equally important. Buyers want to know if the acquisition supports their long-term goals, such as entering untapped markets or gaining access to new technologies. A strong alignment with these objectives can make the deal much more attractive.
Lastly, the deal structure plays a significant role. Whether the payment involves cash, stock, or a combination of both can heavily influence the decision. Each structure carries its own risks and benefits, and buyers carefully weigh these options to determine the best fit for their financial strategy.
How does AI technology impact the buying and selling of businesses in a consolidating market?
AI is reshaping how businesses are bought and sold in industries experiencing consolidation, making processes faster and smarter. Tasks like due diligence, identifying potential targets, and performing valuations become much more efficient as AI processes vast amounts of data with precision. This not only saves time but also helps buyers and sellers make smarter, data-driven decisions.
For small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs), adopting AI has been linked to revenue growth. It improves risk assessments, automates tedious tasks, and sharpens negotiation strategies. By simplifying these crucial steps, AI creates new opportunities for both parties and plays a key role in shaping business valuations in today’s fast-changing marketplace.
Acquire Quality. Fund Growth. Close with Confidence.
As a SaaS-enabled Business Acquisition Marketplace, Financing Platform, and Investment Management Firm, we are on a mission to simplify and accelerate the Small to Medium-Sized Business (SMB) lending and acquisition ecosystem.
We specialize in technology that supports price discovery, identity verification and financial qualification, and buy-side tools to help searchers source and manage deal flow, make offers, secure lending/financing solutions, and close with confidence.
Stay ahead in the dynamic landscape of business acquisitions by exploring our platform's latest blogs, offering insights, trends, and invaluable information to guide you towards informed and strategic decision-making.
Clearly Acquired offers an extensive marketplace equipped with tailored tools, expert guidance, and comprehensive analytics for successful business buying or selling endeavors.
Custom Dashboard
The custom dashboard offers real-time analytics, personalized vendor insights, and streamlined procurement processes for enhanced efficiency and informed decision-making.
Unique User Profile
The customized user profile enables users to create detailed and customizable profiles, fostering meaningful connections by showcasing expertise, interests, and professional achievements.
Curated Business Listings
Clearly Acquired showcases a comprehensive array of business listings, providing detailed information on diverse industries, services, and locations to facilitate informed partnerships and collaborations.
Create Your Listing
Effortlessly create a compelling business listing on our platform, maximizing your exposure to potential buyers and streamlining the selling process.
In-Platform Messaging
With real-time messaging capabilities, you can engage in direct conversations, share insights, and negotiate terms effortlessly.
Connections
Get connected with various people on the platform: business owners, business buyers brokers, consultants, and advisors, and view their profile.
News
Discover the latest developments in the world of business acquisitions with our news tab, offering comprehensive coverage of industry trends and notable transactions.
Get Verified with Plaid
Getting verified on your user profile page is crucial on our business acquisition platform as it enhances trust and credibility within the community.
...And More
This platform can be used in a wide variety of ways and there are new features we are launching regularly! Check back to see what's new and for what we have in store for 2024!
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.png){kind=spacer}
%20Loans%20for%20Business%20Purchases.jpg)
.png){kind=spacer}
%20Loan%20Terms%20vs.%20Other%20Financing%20Options.jpg)
