How to Assess Operational Risks in Acquisitions

70% of mergers and acquisitions fail to deliver expected value because of overlooked operational risks. Here's a quick guide to help you identify and manage these risks effectively:

1. Key Risk Areas to Watch:

   • Supply Chain: Vendor dependencies and disruptions.
   • Staff & Management: Key personnel turnover and productivity loss.
   • Technology Systems: Legacy system issues and cybersecurity vulnerabilities.
   • Legal Compliance: Regulatory gaps and non-transferable licenses.
   • Integration Challenges: Misaligned processes and system incompatibility.

2. Steps to Assess Risks:

   • Review Documents: Analyze workflows, supply chain data, and compliance records.
   • Conduct Site Visits: Inspect infrastructure, equipment, and workflows.
   • Engage Teams: Interview staff to uncover hidden issues.

3. Risk Rating System: Prioritize risks by multiplying probability and impact scores. Focus on critical risks (15-25) first.

4. Mitigation Strategies: Use cost-benefit analysis to choose the most effective solutions, like phased integration or backup plans for supply chain and IT systems.

5. Post-Acquisition Tips:

   • Address critical risks in the first 30 days.
   • Gradually integrate systems and processes.
   • Regularly update contingency plans.

Operations Diligence in M&A | EBITDA Improvement | Mergers and Acquisitions | Grant Thornton

Main Types of Operational Risks

Understanding the key categories of operational risks can significantly sharpen the focus of due diligence efforts.

Supply Chain Vulnerabilities

Supply chain issues can disrupt operations and hurt profitability. A thorough supplier analysis should consider:

Risk Factor	Warning Signs	Impact Level
Supplier Concentration	Dependence on a single supplier	High
Geographic Distribution	Suppliers clustered in one region	Medium
Contract Transferability	Change-of-control clauses in contracts	High
Quality Control	Inconsistent quality assurance processes	Medium
Inventory Management	Inefficient inventory turnover	Medium

This evaluation provides a foundation for addressing broader concerns, such as personnel, technology, legal, and integration risks, ensuring a more comprehensive risk assessment.

Staff and Management Risks

Employee-related risks, particularly the turnover of key personnel, can lead to a 10–20% drop in productivity. These challenges also contribute to integration failures, cited in 47% of deals as a significant issue ^[1].

Tech Systems and Equipment Risks

Operational risks tied to technology and equipment include legacy system compatibility, cybersecurity vulnerabilities, technical debt, software licensing issues, and equipment maintenance. Each of these factors can impact efficiency and scalability.

Legal and Compliance Requirements

Industry-specific regulations and compliance obligations must be carefully reviewed. Ensuring that all permits and licenses are transferable is crucial to avoid fines or disruptions in operations. Beyond regulatory concerns, aligning internal processes is equally important to maintain smooth operations.

Company Integration Challenges

Merging two companies often brings operational misalignments. To minimize integration risks, assess factors like process standardization, system compatibility, customer relationship management, and decision-making frameworks.

Using process mapping can help uncover potential integration obstacles ^[3]. By evaluating current operations alongside post-acquisition goals, businesses can develop strategies to address these challenges effectively.

Steps to Check Operational Risks

Identifying operational risks early is crucial, and a structured, tool-assisted approach can help prevent them from escalating.

Risk Assessment Setup

Once you've pinpointed potential risk areas, it's time to organize your assessment. This involves creating a framework that examines vulnerabilities across all relevant departments. Assemble a cross-functional team with experts from key areas who can bring specialized insights to the table:

Department	Focus Areas	Key Responsibilities
Operations	Process flows, equipment	Analyze production efficiency
Finance	Cost analysis, metrics	Evaluate financial impacts
IT	Systems, security	Assess technology infrastructure
Legal	Compliance, contracts	Ensure regulatory adherence
HR	Staffing, workplace culture	Identify talent and workforce risks

For each role, define specific objectives and criteria to ensure a thorough evaluation. Tools like Clearly Acquired's deal management software can streamline this process, helping you stay organized and avoid oversights.

Information Review

Dive deeply into operational documents to identify risks and pinpoint inefficiencies. Focus on these critical areas:

• Process Documentation: Analyze workflows and standard operating procedures to understand how daily operations are managed.
• Supply Chain Data: Look into vendor contracts, performance metrics, and logistics details to spot potential bottlenecks.
• Production Records: Review maintenance logs, manufacturing capacity, and quality control processes to ensure smooth operations.
• Technology Infrastructure: Check IT systems, software licenses, and cybersecurity measures for vulnerabilities.
• Compliance Records: Scrutinize regulatory filings, audit reports, and certifications for any gaps.

Pay close attention to performance metrics - they often reveal inefficiencies that might otherwise go unnoticed.

Team Meetings and Site Visits

After reviewing the documents, an on-site assessment helps confirm and clarify the risks identified.

• Pre-Visit Planning: Prepare targeted interview guides tailored to each department and role.

• Facility Inspection: Examine the following to get a complete picture:

  • Condition of physical infrastructure
  • Status of production equipment
  • Inventory management systems
  • Technology hardware
  • Safety compliance measures
  • Employee workflow patterns

• Staff Interviews: Gain deeper insights by discussing:

  • How processes are understood and followed
  • Decision-making workflows
  • Problem-solving strategies
  • Any undocumented knowledge or practices

Encourage open and honest feedback by emphasizing that the focus is on improving processes, not evaluating individual performance. Document everything immediately and cross-check findings to ensure consistency. These on-site observations, combined with your document review, provide a comprehensive view of operational risks.

Risk Rating and Solutions

Once you've gathered risk data, the next step is to systematically rate and address those risks. This ensures that all the insights from earlier identification efforts are translated into clear, actionable steps.

Risk Rating System

A simple yet effective way to rate risks is by multiplying their probability and severity scores. This approach provides a clear picture of which risks demand immediate attention and which can be monitored over time.

Risk Level	Probability Score	Impact Score	Action Required
Critical (15-25)	5: Almost certain	5: Severe disruption	Immediate mitigation required
High (10-14)	4: Likely	4: Major impact	Requires detailed action
Medium (5-9)	3: Possible	3: Moderate effect	Monitor and plan response
Low (1-4)	2: Unlikely	2: Minor impact	Regular monitoring
Minimal (0)	1: Rare	1: Negligible	Document and review

To calculate a risk's score, multiply its probability score by its impact score. For instance, if a supply chain disruption has a probability score of 4 (likely) and an impact score of 5 (severe), the total risk score would be 20. This places it in the critical category, requiring immediate attention and action.

This scoring system helps prioritize risks and guides the urgency and design of mitigation plans.

Fix-it Plans and Costs

Once risks are rated, the next step is to develop mitigation strategies, prioritizing the most urgent ones. It's essential to weigh both the cost and effectiveness of each solution to ensure resources are allocated efficiently.

High-Priority Risk Solutions

• Take immediate action using dedicated resources.
• Assign clear ownership and set specific timelines.
• Develop detailed contingency plans to prepare for worst-case scenarios.

Cost-Benefit Analysis Framework

To evaluate the efficiency of mitigation strategies, use this simple formula:

• Risk Reduction Value = Original Risk Cost - Post-mitigation Risk Cost
• Cost-Benefit Ratio = Risk Reduction Value ÷ Total Mitigation Cost

Here’s an example of how this might look for addressing technology integration risks:

Mitigation Strategy	Implementation Cost	Risk Reduction	Cost-Benefit Ratio
Phased Integration	$250,000	$750,000	3.0
System Replacement	$400,000	$900,000	2.25
Parallel Systems	$150,000	$300,000	2.0

In this case, the Phased Integration strategy offers the highest cost-benefit ratio, making it the most efficient use of resources. However, decisions should also account for available budgets and the organization’s risk tolerance. In some cases, combining multiple strategies may be the best approach.

Key Considerations for Fix-it Plans

When designing mitigation strategies, keep these factors in mind:

• Timeline and Resources: Ensure the plan is realistic and achievable within the available timeframe and budget.
• Operational Impact: Minimize disruptions and manage change effectively.
• Monitoring and Measurement: Define clear criteria to track progress and measure success.
• Flexibility: Include mechanisms for regular review and adjustments as conditions evolve.

The goal is to create practical, actionable solutions with clear ownership, specific deliverables, and measurable outcomes. This ensures that mitigation efforts are not only implemented but also deliver the desired results.

sbb-itb-a3ef7c1

After-Purchase Risk Management

Managing operational risks doesn't end with the acquisition. The first 30 days are crucial for addressing high-priority risks and setting the stage for a successful transition.

Merging Business Systems

Gradual implementation of changes can help minimize operational disruptions. Here's a phased approach to integration:

Integration Phase	Timeline	Focus Areas	Key Actions
Immediate	First 30 days	Critical systems	Data backup, parallel processing setup
Short-term	31–90 days	Core operations	Process alignment, staff training
Long-term	91–180 days	Full integration	System optimization, efficiency improvements

Key areas to prioritize during integration include:

1. Technology Infrastructure
   Begin with a comprehensive systems audit to uncover compatibility issues. During critical transitions, maintain parallel systems to ensure uninterrupted operations. For example, when merging ERP systems, run both platforms simultaneously for at least 60 days to thoroughly test data migration and process integration.

2. Process Alignment
   Document workflows from both organizations and create detailed process maps. Standardize essential operations, such as accounting and customer service, to maintain consistent service levels throughout the transition.

3. Data Migration
   Conduct data migration with rigorous testing, clear governance, and full audit trails to ensure accuracy and reliability.

Once systems are integrated, it's essential to establish contingency measures to safeguard operations.

Backup Plans

Contingency planning is vital for addressing potential challenges during the integration process. Develop specific response plans for high-impact risks to maintain operational stability.

Emergency Response Framework

Risk Category	Primary Backup Plan	Secondary Measures
Supply Chain	Alternative supplier network	Inventory buffers
IT Systems	Redundant systems deployment	Manual processes
Key Personnel	Cross-training program	Talent pipeline
Customer Service	Dedicated transition teams	Enhanced support infrastructure

Here’s how to implement effective backup strategies:

1. Supply Chain Resilience
   Build relationships with multiple suppliers ahead of time. Create inventory buffers for essential components and arrange expedited shipping options with trusted logistics partners.

2. Technology Continuity
   Deploy redundant systems to safeguard critical operations. Additionally, document manual workarounds to ensure processes can continue during system downtime.

3. Knowledge Protection
   Develop detailed documentation of critical procedures and establish strong knowledge transfer protocols. Train backup personnel for key roles to ensure smooth operations in case of unexpected absences.

Regularly test and update your backup plans to ensure they remain effective. Establish clear triggers for activating these plans, and make sure every team member understands their responsibilities in emergency scenarios. During the first year after acquisition, review and refine contingency measures every 90 days to address new risks and adapt to evolving business needs.

To streamline post-acquisition integration, consider using tools like Clearly Acquired, which centralizes resources and advisory support for this critical phase.

Risk Assessment Tools

Modern tools have transformed how businesses approach risk assessment, bringing digital precision and efficiency to due diligence processes.

AI Risk Analysis Tools

Artificial Intelligence is reshaping operational risk assessment by leveraging advanced analytics and predictive capabilities. These AI-powered tools can:

• Analyze vast amounts of operational data to spot patterns and irregularities.
• Predict potential disruptions before they materialize.
• Use Natural Language Processing (NLP) to review contracts and flag compliance issues.
• Examine employee communications and customer feedback to uncover hidden risks.

AI Capability	Primary Function	Risk Assessment Benefit
Predictive Analytics	Pattern Recognition	Identifies potential operational failures before they occur.
NLP Processing	Document Analysis	Flags compliance issues in contracts and policies automatically.
Machine Learning	Continuous Improvement	Improves risk detection accuracy over time.
Sentiment Analysis	Stakeholder Feedback	Reveals risks in workplace culture and service delivery.

These AI-driven tools integrate seamlessly into broader risk assessment strategies, offering a powerful complement to human expertise. Together, they bring precision and efficiency to the process.

Risk Management Forms

Digital risk management forms provide structured templates to ensure a consistent and thorough evaluation across all acquisitions.

• Risk Control Self-Assessment (RCSA) Framework
  This template offers a comprehensive overview of enterprise-wide risks, including:

  • Weaknesses in the supply chain.
  • Technology infrastructure challenges.
  • Human resource limitations.
  • Regulatory compliance requirements.

• Due Diligence Checklist
  A systematic tool for tracking:

  • Reviews of operational processes.
  • Assessments of system compatibility.
  • Verification of regulatory compliance.
  • Evaluation of integration risks.

• Risk Register Template
  This document helps record and manage:

  • Identification and categorization of risks.
  • Metrics to assess potential impacts.
  • Probability calculations for risk occurrence.
  • Mitigation strategies and their progress.

Clearly Acquired's platform incorporates these digital tools into its deal management hub, helping acquirers streamline risk assessments while ensuring thorough documentation. With AI-enhanced tools, the platform can flag risks that might go unnoticed using traditional methods.

While technology makes the risk assessment process faster and more precise, human judgment remains essential. Combining digital tools with expert insights ensures risks are not only identified but effectively addressed.

Conclusion: Main Points for Risk Assessment

Carrying out an effective risk assessment requires a clear, systematic approach, supported by the right tools and expertise. It’s worth noting that up to 70% of mergers and acquisitions fail to deliver their expected value, often due to overlooked operational risks ^[1]. To avoid such pitfalls, focus on these key areas:

Key Areas of Risk Assessment

A thorough framework should evaluate these critical areas:

Risk Area	Key Focus	Impact
Supply Chain	Vendor dependencies, logistics	High
Technology	System compatibility, security	Critical
Human Capital	Personnel retention, culture	High
Compliance	Regulatory and legal obligations	Critical
Integration	Process and operational synergy	Medium

These areas are essential to monitor during due diligence. According to the M&A Leadership Council's 2024 survey, 62% of acquirers identify operational risk assessment as the most challenging part of due diligence ^[2].

Steps for Post-Acquisition Risk Management

To manage risks effectively after acquisition, consider these steps:

• Document Everything: Keep detailed records of all identified risks and mitigation strategies.
• Prioritize Actions: Focus on the most critical risks first to ensure smooth transitions.
• Monitor Continuously: Regularly track risks and adjust plans as needed.
• Engage Stakeholders: Involve key personnel to maintain alignment and transparency.

Leveraging AI for Smarter Risk Management

AI-powered platforms are transforming risk assessment by analyzing vast amounts of data, predicting disruptions, and offering actionable insights. For instance, tools like Clearly Acquired combine advanced analytics with expert knowledge to simplify risk assessments and address operational challenges effectively.

Ultimately, successful risk assessment goes beyond identifying potential issues - it’s about implementing practical solutions. Using a structured, data-driven approach not only helps acquirers mitigate risks but also positions them to achieve their strategic goals ^[3]. By staying proactive and leveraging the right tools, organizations can navigate complexities with confidence.

FAQs

Create Your Account